Aletta Maria Potgieter, b1c6d4e6 - ALERT - Aletta Maria Potgieter mix up in SAG v8

Presently Antonie Michael Muller, b2c1 has both these women as a wife

I have removed Maria b1c8d1e1 as the wife of Antonie Michiel Muller b2c1 - if it is found that she was his wife we can reinstate.

FIne by me June. I don't feel like going there today.
We have corrected those so many times I can't even count.
Me

Yes, we have to go back to the original documents and check these facts - the document that a lot of people are using that is found here http://dog-on-blues.com/files/gen/potgieter_Feb2006.pdf
is also full of mistakes

to many people can still change profiles - before you add /change information on a profile that's been loaded to GENi more than a month ago - check first if you are really as correct as you think you are. (I talk to myself too now)

Rather start a discussion on what you believe should be different and why before we just change things

@June - thanks for what you do - much appreciated!!

I added Antonie Michiel Muller's death notice. On page 3 " "...Death notice and Inventories of property of the late Anthony Michael Muller and surviving widow Maria Potgieter."

Thank you ladies.

The b section of the lineage of Harmen Janz Potgieter are as Follow according to Eric Swardt.
It had previously been under discussion and had been acknowledge as correct. As it still seems to be an issue I gladly give the names in birth order
b1 Johannes (Jan Harmensz) Potgieter bapt.9/23/1674
b2 Frederik 2/28/1677
b3 Catharina 11/26/1679
b4 Elizabeth 6/28/1682
b5 Amerentia 9/17/1684
b6 Maria 8/31/1687
b7 Hans Jurgen 7/16/1690
b8 Beatrix 3/17/1693
The Aletta Maria`s mentioned through the whole book are the following
1 b1c6d4e6
2 b1c8d1e1)
3 b1c8d1e7) 2 and 3 are half sisters e7 died at the birth of her daughter
Aletta Maria Ferreira
4 b1c8d3e6f9g1h2
5 b1c8d4
6 b7c8d3e2f6
7 b7c8d8e7f12g6
7 b7c9d3e6f2g5h4
There maybe more of them.

According to the book I am referring to. b1c8d1e1 Aletta Maria Potgieter married Anthonie Michiel Muller b2c1 and her halfsister b1c8d1e7 Aletta Maria Potgieter Maried Thomas Ignatius Ferreira, she died during the birth of her daughter Aletta Maria Ferreira 1825.

Theodorus Daniel Potgieter b1c8d3e3f1 Born Sep 1809 married Martha Jacoba Muller born 1815 Port Elizabeth Daughter of Anthonie Michiel Muller and Aletta Maria Potgieter d1e1 (Keeping the brains in the family)

So I have no doubt that they married as above.

Sorry I have to correct myself otherwise you will do it. Those two Aletta Maria`s weren't half sisters they were own sisters.

( my brother in law at one time brought me some small "halfmens" plants from South Africa. ( I don't know the English name for them ) It is plants with a long stem and bushy head of green leaves . He wasn't suppose to declare the plants at the border post but his honesty get the better of him and he told Immigration that he have three HALFPEOPLE in the car. The short answer was. "They have to report at the counter with their passports"

Chuckle!

In your book is b1c8d1e1 Aletta Maria Potgieter Aletta maria or Maria?

What you are saying is that Muller didn't marry Maria Potgieter, b1c8d1e1?

This plant? http://www.mdseedlings.co.za/pictures/Hen___Chicken.jpg

Did you look at the baptism that was mail to you June?

This plant? http://www.plantzafrica.com/plantnop/pachynam.htm

Yes thanks Marie!

They say you should not drink and drive ...
well we should also not drink and do Genealogy ... :-)

Thank you all for helping out to get each profile perfectly the best we can ...

that is all I have to add here .. now I am off to finish a line that needs to be done before the sun set .. almost done .. well - will never be done - cause after this it needs to be worked into the greater POTGIETER-line and then need to seek some more information on what is missing or suspicious at the moment :-)

Dries what book are you referring to if I may ask?

Maria is e1
Alette Maria is e7

Peter Dennis is Correct with the names. I have changed my book
Pieter Taljaard is correct with the plant.

Willa don't be so nosey. It is Die Potgieter Familie in Suid-Afrika
Die Nageslag van Harmen Janz Potgieter deur Eric Swardt.

I will be gone for a few days so I cant answer any more Questions

Not sure I understand the reference to drinking Willa??? :-)

I notices that Antonie Michiel Muller, b2c1 was remove from Maria Potgieter b1c8d1e1 as a husband. I strongly believe that she was the husband of b2c1. If you look at the witness, maybe we find the link.

The baptism doc for JOHANNES bap 5 Aug 1798.
Father; Antonie Michiel Muller b2c1
Mother: Maria Potgieter
Witness: Theodorus Potgieter ( b1c8d1e3)? her brother?
Susanna Elizabeth Muller b10

The baptism doc for ANTONY MIGAEL bap 7 Mar 1803
Father; Antonie Michiel Muller b2c1
Mother: Maria Potgieter
Witness: Gerrit van Rooyen
Martha Johanna Muller
Isac Potgieter ( b1c8d1e4)? her brother?
Susanna Elizabeth Muller

The baptism doc for CORNELIS JOHANNES bap 22 nov 1795
Father: Antonie Michiel Muller b2c1
Mother: Maria Potgieter
Witness: Cornelis Johannes Muller
Johanna van Rooyen

I agree with Marie Boshoff. The dates in the documents provide positive clues... The reference of Maria Potgieter and Antonie Michiel Muller b2c1, his date of death 1843.

DEPOT KAB
SOURCE MOOC
TYPE LEER
VOLUME_NO 7/1/171
SYSTEM 01
REFERENCE 116
PART 1
DESCRIPTION POTGIETER, MARIA. WIFE OF ANTHONY MICHAEL MULLER. WILL.
STARTING 18430000
ENDING 18430000
REMARKS FILED 1843.

DEPOT KAB
SOURCE MOOC
TYPE LEER
VOLUME_NO 7/1/202
SYSTEM 01
REFERENCE 100
PART 1
DESCRIPTION POTGIETER, MARIA. WIFE OF ANTHONY MICHAEL MULLER. WILL.
STARTING 18480000
ENDING 18480000
REMARKS FILED 1850.

DEPOT KAB
SOURCE MOOC
TYPE LEER
VOLUME_NO 6/9/51
SYSTEM 00
REFERENCE 344
PART 1
DESCRIPTION MULLER, MARIA. (NEE POTGIETER). DEATH NOTICE.
STARTING 1850
ENDING 1850

The Aletta Maria Potgieter married to Anthony Michael Muller (below) date is 1834

DEPOT KAB
SOURCE MOOC
TYPE LEER
VOLUME_NO 7/1/122
SYSTEM 01
REFERENCE 60
PART 1
DESCRIPTION POTGIETER, ALETTA MARIA. WIFE OF ANTHONY MICHAEL MULLER. WILL.
STARTING 18330000
ENDING 18330000
REMARKS FILED 1834.

Martin Andreas Karl Potgieter, jy gee lewe, kleur en goeie dosis plesier aan Geni en ons besprekings!!

Martin Andreas Karl (Dries) Potgieter can you look at this please - I am not well :-( and going to bed

Hi June,
I have no other sources than My "book" and the usual SAG volumes. Marie and Charlene have such good documentation and are so convincing that I feel we can take their findings as correct if Peter Dennis and Pieter Taljaard as well as you agree. . We can just put in the history part some note that the profiles was under discussion and we have come to this Conclusion So that posterity cant blame us for being asleep.

Hi,

See the documents attach to the children. Under Source.

I agree Dries - do you want to process this - I am away for a few days from tomorrow with no internet - but can help later today. Feeling much better thanks to antib's

Daniel Jacobus Botes, g2h3 you have a curator note on Antonie Michael Muller, b2c1

What are your thoughts here?

June, looking at your note you will notice that although Anthonie is labeled b2c1, my note was on his first cousin b1c5 which means that here we might have had wrong merges or errors also in SAG vol 5

SAG vol 5 p 714 states
b1c5 Antonie Michael » 24.1.1779 x Kaapstad 15.1.1804 Johanna Catharina DU PREEZ d.v. Andries du Preez en Hester Ferreira xx Graaff-Reinet 2.5.1813 Aletta Maria POTGIETER » 5.10.1794 d.v. Cornelis Potgieter en Rachel Lea Meyer
here b1c5 x Aletta Maria on SAG vol 8 p 218

SAG Vol 5 p 715 states
b2c1 Antonie Michiel » 24.3.1771 † Uitenhage 21.1.1843 x Aletta Maria POTGIETER » 12.4.1778 † 1850 d.v. Johannes Potgieter en Agatha Catharina Meyer
here b2c1 x Aletta Maria on SAG Vol 8 p 253

Clearly the above indicates DIFFERENT Anthonie Michiel/Michael Mullers and DIFFERENT Aletta Maria Potgieters

CONCLUSION 1: The two Aletta Maria Potgieters are both show as wives since the 2 Anthonie Michiel/Michael have been incorrectly merged.

CONCLUSION 2: The wrong information currently appears in the curator note of b2c1

CONCLUSION 3: We might have removed the wrong Aletta Maria from the right Anthonie Michiel

CONCLUSION 4: We have to check that we have not incorrectly linked Michiel to Michael / Michael to Michiel in the MOOC's

CONCLUSION 5: We must thoroughly check both Anthonies b1c5 and b2c1 to ensure that all the contributive evidence now correlate

Marie , Charlene , Daan, Please take over and sort it out. I don't want to be in Junes, bad books when she comes back. I really haven't got the sources , know how to handle this. Please , Please, assebliefffff.

I have 3 ladies to help me sorting this out. I will take the lead once all had the opportunity to se whether they agree.
Dries, moenie worry nie - die "manne van die sand" kyk na mekaar se belange!

Just checking in to check out - I cannot do anything on this until I get back - happy to get my head around it then, by which time hopefully i will be over this illness too! Just haven't been able to think straight this last few days. I will work with you next week Daan if everyone is happy to wait? Dries - I really don't bite!! I trust your judgement - we can weigh it all up next week! The places we are camping at don't even have power let alone wi-fi!We will be relying on the van's battery power!

On the other hand if you have it all sorted by the time I get back that will be just fine! :-)

Thank you all - I am in Cape Town - if I need to go to archives - please let me know via willa.truter@gmail.com - I check that more often than here ... I will got and get what we need and bring back ... but only as needed - thanks for taking the lead on this Daan .... just let me know how I can be helpful too if needed.

Willa