data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fbeb0/fbeb0a44bd372b3fca219a0a6e57ec126381b2b1" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a643d/a643d4f526d0e3a696dd867e97314a05fe7216bb" alt=""
Not the same as Bathsheba Holmes or as Barsheba Barlow. There were two or three Bathsheba Stetsons in Scituate at this time.
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Stetson-1256
Birth
Bathsheba Stetson was born in September, 1693 at Scituate, Massachusetts. [1] She was the 3rd child daughter of Joseph Stetson and Hannah (Oldham) Stetson.[2]
Marriage
Married First (1): Samuel Gardener, Jr. [A] [B] of Pembroke, 30 Jan 1722.[3], at Pembroke, Massachusetts (as his 2nd wife) [4]
Children: (Recorded by FamilySearch [5])
(Poss) Married Second (2): Shubael Barlow
3 Children:
Death
She dies in March 1763 in Massachusetts. [6]
Stetson Kindred Genealogical Index: 1-1-1-3.
A. Bathsheba's Family Tree page on FamilySearch.org [7] lists an additional marriage to Shubael Barlow without any sources. They also list 4 children born to the couple. The Stetson Kindred does not record this marriage in their Genealogy, [3] and there are notes on the FamilySearch.org page [8] that suggest that there were two Bathsheba Stetsons in Scituate at this time. This Bathsheba's marriage is recorded here.
B. Samuel Gardener is also listed by FamilySearch.org as Samuel Gardner, Jr. Some of the documents on his record there also shows the family name as "Garner" [9] His First wife was Lydia Oldham, 2 Jul 1707. [10]
1693 |
September 29, 1693
|
Scituate, Plymouth County, Massachusetts, British Colonial America
|
|
1726 |
December 18, 1726
|
Pembroke, Plymouth County, Massachusetts, United States
|
|
1742 |
December 18, 1742
Age 49
|
Pembroke, Plymouth County, Massachusetts, British Colonial America
|