Robert B. Caldwell - Need a curator please and thank you. This is from the inbox:

Managers of Robert B. Caldwell,

I am contacting you about this profile AGAIN
Robert B. Caldwell

Robert B Caldwell b 1719 in Somerset, MD -died 1806 Worcester MD m Winifred Watts 1729-1806
Child Spencer born 1742 Somerset, MD and lived later in NC

has erroneously been merged and overwritten “Robert Caldwell” of Cub Creek, VA. Children and facts now mixed.

Correct
Robert Caldwell b 1732 Cub Creek, Lunenberg, VA (now Charlotte,VA) d 1806 Mercer Kentucky m Mary Logan Jan 1755 and buried Caldwell-Irvine cemetery Danville, Boyle, KY Find a Grave 46565744

DAR reference is this one b 1732

Children born Cub Creek, Lunenberg, VA (now Charlotte,VA)
Margaret P Caldwell Cook 1755-1844
John C Caldwell 1758-1804
David Caldwell 1760-
William T Caldwell 1762-1827
Robert Caldwell 1764-1837
Phillips Caldwell 1767-1817. ( named for Margaret Phillips)
Jenny Caldwell Logan 1770-1827
Mary Logan Caldwell Palmer 1773-1836
Elizabeth Caldwell Grundy 1776-1807
James Logan Caldwell 1778-1850
Richard Caldwell 1781-1782

Sibling Rev James Caldwell (Apr 1734 Charlotte VA-Nov 1781 Elizabethtown, NJ ) is well documented for Revolutionary War m Hannah Ogden similarly attributed to parentage John Caldwell

Will David Logan probated 1763 mentions daughter Mary Caldwell naming Robert in Danville KY executor
check possible problem other mixed info

Father-John of Cub Creek
John Finley Caldwell 1683 Ireland-1750 Cub Creek Lunenberg, VA (now Charlottte, VA) -son of Joseph Alexander Caldwell 1655-1732 and Jane McGhie 1660-1691
married 1704 Mary Margaret Phillips 1685 Ireland -1748 Charlotte, VA

Geneanet lists -different middle name not recognized.
John Francis Caldwell 1682-1750 in Charlotte, VA
Married 1704 Mary Margaret Phillips

Detach Robert B Caldwell with wife Winifred and son Spencer
Thank you.

Restore Robert Caldwell m Mary Logan
Sincerely,

A