I see that Alice Parke was the Great-Great-Great Granddaughter of Sir James Framlingham who, in turn, was a descendent of the Plantagenet kings. In the notes included in Alice's profile, it says "Her ancestry has been traced to the early Saxon and Scottish kings, bypassing the later Norman kings." My questions: 1. Is the line to Sir James and thence to the Plantagenet kings correct? 2. What is the source for the line to the early Saxon kings? and 3. Shouldn't she be included in the canonical list of "New England Ancestors of Proven Royal Descent?" Thanks for your input! -- John Cowles
Notes here
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Freeman-1326
Disproved Royal Ancestry
A Royal Ancestry was developed and published for Alice Freeman to John, king of England. This was repeated in multiple secondary sources.[14] This line has been broken in two places. First, it has been shown that Joan de Harley, wife of John de Besford, was not a daughter of Sir Robert de Harley by his wife Joan Corbet. [18] [19] Second, Margaret ferch Llewelyn is no longer considered a granddaughter of John, king of England.
Notable Kin
She is called an ur-mother of American genealogy by Gary Boyd Roberts of the NEHGS in his Notable Kin series because of the tremendous number descendants she left, including a large number of notable and important persons. This includes the current royal family of England, as she is the 10th great-grandmother of Diana, princess of Wales. She is often the closest common ancestor for many Americans to the British royal family. She is also an ancestor of the American tycoon families of tycoon families of the Firestones, Fords, McCormicks, Rockefellers, Tiffanys, Whitneys, and J.P Morgan. [20] [21] [22] [23]
https://groups.google.com/forum/m/#!topic/soc.genealogy.medieval/UU...
-----
https://www.americanancestors.org/StaticContent/articles?searchby=a...
#68 Royal Descents, Notable Kin, and Printed Sources: Notable Descendants of Mrs. Alice Freeman Thompson Parke, RD
Gary Boyd Roberts
Found the problem!! It's @Sir James Fremingham, Baron of Fremingham and Glassenbury - he seems to be completely unsourced! Supposedly a descendant of King John through his mother, @Lady Agnes Fremington (Wingfield), and the father of @Sir Henry R. Freeman, there seems to be no proof of either connection. Henry R. Freeman is listed often on ancestry.com as being the son of Sir James, but without any source. In the notes to Henry Freeman on Wikitree the profile manager states: "Online sources have been found suggesting he could be the son of Sir James Fremingham and Elizabeth Fremingham - this is incorrect. There is no evidence this true, the name is wrong, and the location is wrong. SOURCE IN ERROR." Could a curator please fix this? Thank you! Sincerely, John Cowles
http://www.treetreetree.org.uk/FreemanAlice.htm#8 (which has a good pedigree for Alice Freeman it looks like) has no parents for Henry Freeman, of Irchester
I am disconnecting from not his parents Sir James Framlingham & Alice Framlingham and adding NN relationship locked placeholder parents.
I believe you’ve found a bogused pedigree and earned Your Geni Angel Wings
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Freeman-470 is good and lists additional resources, especially his will.
I think Henry’s children need to be checked against it.
Can we compare the profile here
Also tagging Hatte Blejer on hiatus this leads to Edmund Freeman, yeoman, of Pulborough you curate and the English tree for him is looking location confused